All articlesFor Careers Teams

    Gatsby Benchmarks and Destinations Data After Milburn: How Careers Teams Can Evidence Impact

    The MyPathfinder Team8 min read

    Most careers leaders can show their programme against the Gatsby Benchmarks. Far fewer can show what it changed. The Milburn Review has made that the question that matters: schools are measured on exam results rather than where young people end up, colleges are funded for enrolment rather than sustained destinations, and careers guidance is "a statutory duty without enforcement" (Schools Week). Here is how the benchmarks and destinations data fit together, and a practical way to evidence impact before anyone asks.

    What are the eight Gatsby Benchmarks?

    The Gatsby Benchmarks, developed by Sir John Holman for the Gatsby Foundation, define good careers guidance and sit in the statutory guidance for schools and colleges in England:

    1. A stable careers programme
    2. Learning from career and labour market information
    3. Addressing the needs of each young person
    4. Linking curriculum learning to careers
    5. Encounters with employers and employees
    6. Experiences of workplaces
    7. Encounters with further and higher education
    8. Personal guidance

    Searches for the Gatsby Benchmarks are small but steady on Google, and they sit alongside the National Careers Service and the CDI as the most searched terms around careers guidance. They are the shared language of careers leaders, governors and inspectors.

    What did the Milburn Review say about destinations?

    The interim report in May 2026 argued that the system measures the wrong things. It also found that the LEO dataset, which links education records to earnings and benefits, is not routinely available to colleges, local authorities or strategic bodies (FE News). Milburn told FE Week that an outcomes-based funding system for colleges is both necessary and achievable (FE Week).

    The final report on 17 November set a target to cut the NEET rate from 13% to around 5% by 2036 and proposed a Youth Opportunity Service with a named adviser for every young person (ITV News). Nothing on destinations accountability is law yet, but the direction is set. We cover the full report in the Milburn Review for careers teams.

    What does national destinations data show?

    The latest published destinations, for students who left in 2024 (DfE, via Pathways):

    Measure After key stage 4 After 16 to 18 study
    Sustained destination (headline) 91.3%, down 0.4 points 77.5%, down 1.5 points
    Sustained education 86.2% 43.4%
    Sustained apprenticeship 3.0% 7.0%
    Sustained employment 2.1% 27.2%
    Not sustained or not tracked 8.7% 22.5%

    For universities, the latest Graduate Outcomes survey found 87% of 2023/24 graduates in work or further study around 15 months after finishing, with unemployment up a point to 7% (HESA). Median earnings five years after graduating were £33,300 (DfE LEO, via Pathways).

    Two limits matter. First, the data is slow: 2024 leavers' destinations were published in 2026. Second, it is national. Your own institution's figure is what you will be asked about.

    Why is destinations data hard to use?

    Ofsted's independent review of careers guidance found that leaders in schools and further education and skills providers can use destinations data to improve their careers provision, but some found it difficult in practice because of time and data protection requirements (Ofsted, GOV.UK). The same review found that both schools and FE providers found the Gatsby Benchmarks useful for reviewing their programmes strategically.

    So most teams have the framework but not the evidence loop. Published destinations arrive too late to change anything for the students they describe.

    How can careers teams evidence impact?

    Build the evidence in three layers, from what you control to what you influence.

    Layer 1: Activity against the benchmarks. What you delivered, to whom and when. Encounters with employers, workplace experiences, personal guidance meetings. The Careers & Enterprise Company's Compass tools are the standard way to track this for schools and colleges. This proves the programme exists. It does not prove it worked.

    Layer 2: Student engagement. What students did with it. Who built a CV, practised an interview, researched a sector, applied for something. This is where most programmes have no data at all, and it is the earliest signal of who is on track and who is drifting.

    Layer 3: Outcomes. Where students went and whether it stuck. Your own leaver follow-up at three and six months, local authority tracking for 16 and 17 year olds, national destinations and Graduate Outcomes when they arrive.

    The link between layers 2 and 3 is the story a governor, inspector or funder wants: students who engaged with employability support were more likely to reach a sustained destination.

    Which benchmarks are hardest to evidence?

    In practice, three:

    • Benchmark 2, labour market information. It changes monthly, and few teams have time to keep it current. Our monthly labour market briefing for careers teams and Pathways are built to cover it.
    • Benchmark 3, addressing the needs of each young person. It needs records of individual progress, not just whole-cohort activity.
    • Benchmark 8, personal guidance. One meeting is easy to log. Showing what the student did next is not.

    What should careers leaders do this year?

    • Know your own destinations. By route and by group, not just the headline. If you cannot, start with your own follow-up.
    • Measure engagement, not just attendance. Track what students do between guidance meetings.
    • Report outcomes alongside activity. Governors and senior leaders should see both.
    • Keep labour market information current. Students make choices on what the market looks like now, not two years ago.
    • Prepare for accountability before it arrives. The teams that already tell an outcomes story will shape how it is measured.

    How does MyPathfinder support the Gatsby Benchmarks?

    MyPathfinder supports Gatsby Benchmarks 2, 3, 5 and 8. Students get a CV builder trained on UK hiring standards, interview practice with feedback after every answer, job search and live UK labour market information. Your team gets an anonymous engagement dashboard showing CVs created, interviews practised and the job titles and locations students are applying for, with a Power BI feed and board-ready reports.

    For teams who need the outcomes layer, MyPathfinder's consultancy builds destinations and local labour market reviews for colleges, sixth forms and universities. Talk to us at mypathfinder.uk/educators

    Gatsby BenchmarksDestinationsCareers GuidanceMilburn ReviewCareers Leaders

    For careers and employability teams

    See the live UK early-careers market on Pathways, free and updated daily, or talk to us about supporting your students with our platform and consultancy.

    Built for careers teams

    Pathways shows the UK early-careers market live, with every figure sourced. When you are ready to support your students, we are here.